Print

The right to access to justice

03 May 2017

The most terrible thing that can happen to anyone is the loss of a child. In some tragic cases the intolerable situation is aggravated by people indifference.

M. approached me with a complaint on improper conduct of the procedural audition on the death of her son. According to the woman, in November last year her son N. participated in illegal competitions on underwater hunting on the Smirnovka River in Krasnodar Territory.

The organizers of the tournament deceived the participants, ensuring compliance with all necessary security measures. However, no instructors, no insurance, no special equipment for the organization of rescue operations were provided. A doctor on duty on the day of the tragedy was not on the shore.

Underwater hunting is considered a dangerous sport. According to the case materials, one of the organizers sent N. into the water, despite the lack of professional skills of the young man, and fixed the equipment without ensuring a safe dropping of the cargo. During the swim in the middle of the river, N. drowned.

In the application, M. complained about prolonged bureaucracy and formalism on the part of law enforcement agencies, the lack of a procedural assessment of the actions of the organizers of the competition, the lack of notification by the investigator about the results of the inspection, which entailed the violation of her rights to access to justice. In addition, M. applied for interviews with witnesses and information on the investigation materials, but always received refusals. For several months the woman was completely helpless.

Having familiarized myself with the materials of the complaint, I sent a request to the Investigative Directorate of the Investigation Committee of Russia in Krasnodar Territory.

Based on the results of the additional inspection, the investigating authorities initiated a criminal case on causing death by negligence. The applicant was recognized as a victim.

The cynicism of officials in this matter causes outrage. Unfortunately, the young man can not be returned, but I did everything within my powers to defend his mother’s right to justice.

We did it...
Dialogue with society. Family’s right to early childhood education restored

Dialogue with society. Family’s right to early childhood education restored

22 July 2021
A little more than a month remains until the beginning of the school year. Not only schoolchildren and students but also young children want to study. Whilst the legislation guarantees the availability of places in educational institutions, parents sometimes face difficulties when they want to enroll a child in a preschool group. High Commissioner for Human Rights in the Russian Federation…
Dialogue with society. Student’s right to scholarship restored

Dialogue with society. Student’s right to scholarship restored

21 July 2021
In 2020 the important innovation was the gradual transition of payments to automatic mode. This means that a person does not need to write an application and collect documents. This timely measure has become particularly relevant to the pandemic. However, sometimes, people face different problems. A mother of the student from the Kursk region requested High Commissioner for Human…
Dialogue with society. Mother and newborn child were transferred to a specialized institution

Dialogue with society. Mother and newborn child were transferred to a specialized institution

16 July 2021
The birth of a child is the most important event in the life of any family, for which they begin to prepare long before childbirth. This is a very joyful and exciting day for everyone: parents, relatives, doctors. Resident of the Moscow region B., who could not contact her daughter in the maternity hospital for several days, asked High Commissioner…
We did it...