Print

Supreme Court changed the rules of dealing with “likes” and “reposts” cases

20 September 2018
Supreme Court changed the rules of dealing with “likes” and “reposts” cases

On September 20, Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation adopted a resolution supplementing the rules for the consideration of cases related to likes and reposts in social networks.

The Supreme Court explained that the initiation of criminal cases on the placement of extremist materials in the Internet is possible only with the determination of intent to foster hatred or ill will.

"The Criminal Code of Russia does not provide for the prosecution of reposts, only of the incitement of hatred. Even in case the material is extremist, and a person has copied it to his page, it does not mean anything. It is necessary to prove the intent," judge of the Supreme Court Vladimir Davydov said.

High Commissioner for Human Rights in the Russian Federation Tatiana Moskalkova has repeatedly noted that she supports the initiative to decriminalize articles of the Criminal Code that provide for criminal sanctions for reposts and likes in social networks. According to the High Commissioner, having reposted information, a person often can not fully assess its social danger and determine if it may cause ominous effects.

"I stand against criminal prosecution for reposts," the ombudswoman said, responding to questions from young human rights activists at the Russian Educational Youth Forum «Terra Scientia on Klyazma River». "From the legal point of view, it is very important to ascertain malice. The created content can be harmful to society, a particular person or the state. <…> But when a person does not understand that he has reposted a harmful „fake“, he is innocent as far as he had no any malicious intent, unlike the author, who knew for sure that he wanted to sow panic or commit acts that destabilize society".

An example of dissemination of such false information is the distribution of «fake» news about the tragedy in the city of Kemerovo, which happened on March 25 in the shopping center «Zimnyaya Vishnya». News about hundreds of people killed in the fire and inaction of law enforcement agencies was spread in the Internet. However, this information was not supported by any evidence. In addition, scammers speculating on the tragedy, published sham bank accounts data for people to transfer money to help the victims.

In the opinion of Tatiana Moskalkova, the creation and deliberate dissemination of unreliable information aimed at destabilizing the society and calling people for participation in unauthorized rallies should be barred and prosecuted. But bringing people to criminal responsibility for «unmalicious» likes and reposts is a disproportionately strict measure of restraint.

News of the High Commissioner
High Commissioner’s initiative to ban cages from courtrooms

High Commissioner’s initiative to ban cages from courtrooms

20 June 2019
On June 18, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation has supported a legislative initiative to abolish cages in the courtrooms, and this issue is now widely discussed by supporters and opponents of this idea. However, High Commissioner for Human Rights in the Russian Federation Tatiana Moskalkova has expressed the need to abolish the practice of using metal cages in courtrooms in March,…
Dialogue with High Commissioner. Right to favourable environment

Dialogue with High Commissioner. Right to favourable environment

17 June 2019
We all live on the same planet. The earth is our common home which we should keep clean and in order. Nature has given all the essentials: clean air, drinking water, food. Our health and longevity directly depend on their quality. But humanity is moving on and trying to adapt the environment to its own interests, in which profit takes precedence.…
Statement of the Commissioner for Human Rights in the Russian Federation

Statement of the Commissioner for Human Rights in the Russian Federation

09 June 2019
I have noted with attention the recent statement made by the Secretary General of the Council of Europe Thorbjørn Jagland with regard to the situation of investigative journalist Ivan Golunov who had been detained by law-enforcement officers in Moscow. From day one I took this case under my special control and stayed in close touch with the lawyer of the detained journalist. It is known…
News of the High Commissioner